As of this morning, there is still no public comment on the Obama administration's plan to name a national Chief Technology Officer (CTO). So, as the stimulus legislation transitions from front page news story to funding for federal agencies, we decided to take a look at some of the potential reasons why we have not heard an update regarding the CTO.
Round Peg, Square Hole
Perhaps one reason the Obama administration has not been able to name a CTO is the administration is having trouble crafting the position. Finding a place either within an existing organization or as a new addition to the already crowded West Wing could be harder than anticipated. Considering the vast network of issues the CTO must touch on a regular basis – technology implementation, IT policy, HealthIT, GreenIT, cyber security and transparency/efficiency – there might not be an easy spot.
Thanks, but No Thanks
As some have hypothesized, potential candidates have not accepted the position because it does not have enough authority. Whether potential CTOs are looking for budget or policy authority (or both), there is no incumbent or mold for this position thus making it somewhat risky for seasoned professionals. It is likely the CTO will need to be an authority either within the executive branch or within the administration to be effective – policy, budget, advisory or a new version of one of the three.
We've Got This Covered
Perhaps there is no unique need for a CTO because Obama has fulfilled all necessary roles with other nominations, for example: OMB e-Gov Director Kundra, cyber security advisor (Melissa Hathaway), and other leadership roles, including Chief Performance Officer (CPO). In a related possibility, just as the CPO was merged with a leadership position at OMB, the administration could be planning to rework the CTO position into one or several other positions. If so, the CTO would best be distributed across the advisors and policy makers who oversee the IT budget(s), CIOs, government-wide performance issues, and someone who still could have a hand in implementation.
Time is Money
One obvious reason we have not seen a CTO nomination or clarification lately is there has not been enough time. Time is limited and the priorities associated with the economy, recession, stimulus package and nominations for key departments like Commerce and HHS have taken precedent. In fact, it is likely that many of Obama's timelines have been skewed due to the tour associated with the economic stimulus process, the reaction to TARP and unplanned obstacles with the aforementioned nominations.
It's Not You, It's Me
Let's be honest, it is possible that Obama has not found the right person. We can all assume that some vetting has taken place, perhaps even an offer for the role, but while reviewing all the options, we should address the fact that the appropriate person has not been chosen because the appropriate person has not been found. If Obama is sincere about reworking how government operates and understands the complexities of this role, it is also likely he's holding back until the best possible match can be found.
The Last Word
As long as we're going through all the options (even though we have not seen any evidence of this), it is also possible the administration could be rethinking the nomination of a CTO. With all the other priorities and issues to focus on, the administration is not ready to establish this position and define all its roles. So, perhaps we won't see a CTO and instead the administration has sped past this position to deal with national priorities.
On the other hand, this position cannot do everything for anyone. So finding someone who is capable of being well-versed in public and private processes and navigating both the contracting, policy and political issues on a national stage is unlikely. So, just as the administration is currently prioritizing economic issues dealing with those that require immediate attention, the future CTO will have to do that same thing once they take office and ultimately, that's the name of the game this year in Washington D.C.